For understanding of whats happened so far:
After successfully fixing the problem listed above, it instantly gave me a new problem where i cannot access my site internally, meaning any computer or device within the same network as the raspberry pi housing the website.
My domain is: https://www.newkiddintown.com
Not a cache issue, as its with every device in the network and ive cleared cache on all of them. Any ideas on what this could be or if anyone has seen this before?
Before i added the cert, i could access the website just fine internally and externally, right when i added the cert, i could no longer access it internally.