You can try and get a wildcard certificate via the plesk interface. This will force plesk to use the dns challenge and you’ll be able to get a new cert without changing the A/AAAA records, but I don’t know if it will be able to renew automatically.
It make sense, because A/AAAA record of guideastuces.com point to the old server. Of course, I shouldn't change it before I fix certificate on the new server.
it doesn't, wildcard certificates don't use A/AAAA records, only TXT ones. But plesk might be stupid enough to use dns-01 for *.example.com and http-01 for example.com (both are needed)
How much downtime are you comfortable with? Obtaining a certificate doesn't take a lot of time.
You can also obtain a certificate on the old server and upload it on the new one. Make sure to get all domains you need on one certificate (certbot certonly --cert-name newserver -d example.com -d www.example.com -d other.example.com)
In the end, it was an IPv6 address problem. I removed the AAAA records in the old server and the problem is gone.
Thank you, I really appreciate your help