Welcome to the Let's Encrypt Community 
It appears that you have managed to successfully acquire many Let's Encrypt certificates covering wordforge.net and www.wordforge.net):
https://crt.sh/?q=wordforge.net
When you mention the "Let's Encrypt Plugin", I believe you're referring to what is now known as FleetSSL, which is highly discouraged by cPanel. There have been numerous issues with that plugin. The official plugin for managing Let's Encrypt certificates in cPanel is AutoSSL. If you do not have and cannot install AutoSSL, I can recommend using CertSage, the ACME client I authored and optimized for acquiring Let's Encrypt certificates with cPanel hosting.