Welcome @yachtcapt
Yeah, you need to modify your GoDaddy DNS setup. The public DNS should point directly to the public IP of your server. Instead, it is setup to use Domain Forwarding.
We see this fairly often. Below is a good explanation of what to do
Your DNS right now has these two IP addresses. These are services inside of AWS that GoDaddy uses for the Forwarding feature
Name: marine-captain.com
Address: 3.33.251.168
Address: 15.197.225.128