Global DNS synchronization takes some time.
That said,
toddmatthews.me nameserver = dns2.registrar-servers.com
toddmatthews.me nameserver = dns1.registrar-servers.com
and
Server: dns1.registrar-servers.com shows:
Name: www.toddmatthews.me Address: 45.55.255.59
Server: dns2.registrar-servers.com shows:
Name: www.toddmatthews.me Address: 45.55.255.59
So this DNS out-of-sync problem should be back in-sync now.
I would try it again (maybe with --dry-run = just in case)