I’m having a problem with an old (revoked) certificate issued for a domain name that has been deprecated and replaced with a new domain (and a new certificate) on the same server (the same IP).
Whenever a new domain is accessed, the browser shows “the identity of the website can not be verified” warning and offers to trust the (old?) certificate for the old domain name.
Sounds like your web server doesn’t know which certificate it should deliver. Could you provide your web server configuration files? If you’re using apache, the VirtualHost blocks would probably be the most relevant. I’m guessing there’s some reference to the old certificate in there.