Yes! Any user input would be immensely more helpful than what that list is now. Because what else do we have with the current list? Basically links to ads where all those web hosting companies tell us “how great they are.”
Ideally (and I’m not sure what platform would support this) it would be nice to have columns with features of those web hosts. For instance: Country that servers are located in, support for PHP, MySQL, Linux, Windows, disk size, bandwidth limitations (actual vs. advertised), etc.
Then the most useful IMO would be user rating. Just basic up and down arrows and then the overall ups and downs tabulated. This way it would be pretty easy to weed out sh*tty hosts.
Lastly, it would help if there was a comment section per host where registered users can write a short review of the host. (This way it will hopefully prevent “self patting on the back” done by many hosts in the comment section.)