Webmail by servermx.com

No, it isn't; it's a certificate mismatch. For reasons known only to them, servermx.com thinks it's a great idea to tell their customers to set CNAME records as @kban describes above, which is guaranteed to give cert errors (I don't think it can be repeated too frequently, or too strongly, what a bad idea this is). Even if you add an exception, you're going to see warnings.