When using the bitnami documents and the bncert-tool, I kept getting an error,
Warning: The domain 'www.anticipatereality.com' resolves to a different IP
address than the one detected for this machine, which is '<MY External IP>'. Please
fix its DNS entries or remove it. For more info see:
But thank you for sending me down the correct path, when attempting to solve for that error I found this post and it resolved all my remaining issues!
And note for anyone that finds this later, You don't need access to old certs to get a new one. Thank you to MikeMcQ For educating me on that and to schoen