I should note that I didn’t see the error until recently as I was updating my site through WordPress. Some users have alerted me that they have received the error while others have not.
Can someone point me in the right direction on how to fix this issue?
It appears that the 2nd IP is from GoDaddy (who seemed to add their IP in and won't allow us to remove it).
I did run the second check on the SSL and see an error:
The certificate is self-signed. Users will receive a warning when accessing this site unless the certificate is manually added as a trusted certificate to their web browser. You can fix this error by buying a trusted SSL certificate.
It's looking like it might be an issue with GoDaddy. I have to call back tomorrow to figure out why.