Adding a deploy-hook will be helpful so let's work that first. We'll review and delete old certs after.
So, try this
sudo certbot reconfigure --cert-name allcountyguitar.com-0001 --deploy-hook 'sudo service httpd reload'
I know you used restart but reload is less disruptive and is all that is needed.
You will (should be) prompted if you want to run the deploy-hook for --dry-run (testing). An "R" answer to run them is probably best for your case.
Let us know if that worked.