www.wantsomeink.com is using a self-signed certificate. Mind sharing your web server configuration? I’m guessing there’s a reference to that certificate somewhere in there.
You’ll probably want a ServerAlias www.wantsomeink.com in there, otherwise apache might pick any other <VirtualHost> when serving www.wantsomeink.com.
I’m guessing you have another <VirtualHost> that points to a self-signed certificate. You’ll probably be able to find it with grep -r "SSLCertificate" /etc/apache2/.