Certbot up to 5.2.2 blocks requests for IP certificates

Client dev
1

Over a week ago 6-day and IP Address Certificates are Generally Available - Let's Encrypt announced the production availability of IP address certificates was annonuced..

Unfortunately the official-ish client certbot still blocks requests for such certificates with this message:

Requested name ... is an IP address. The Let's Encrypt certificate authority will not issue certificates for a bare IP address.

I have verified this in 4.0.0-2 (what Debian and Ubuntu provide) as well as 5.2.2 (snap and docker-image).

The according function is enforce_domain_sanity() in util.py.

IMO that blockage should be removed, or changed to a warning.

Opinions? Can I help?

This probably should go in the Help category too because this issue might hit others too, but I guess the Client dev category is read by more devs.

2

There's a PR on the Github repository for adding support already, but it seems to take ages.

3

Thanks for the Github hint!

That's where the real discussions happen, and where the IP address certificates are a hot topic indeed.

Relevant PRs include [Feature Request]: IP address subjectAlternativeName certificates · Issue #10346 · certbot/certbot · GitHub, https://github.com/certbot/certbot/pull/10468, https://github.com/certbot/certbot/pull/10495, webroot: add IP address support by jsha · Pull Request #10543 · certbot/certbot · GitHub

4

Yeah, so it looks like support is getting added, that --ip-address CLI option just last week. There hasn't been a release after that yet, so a little bit more patience is required I guess.