I’ve successfully created a certificate for default web site on this server, but I am unable to do it for an additional site. Any help is appreciated. Thanks.
It was the firewall. The first site that worked fine was on a different ip address. I thought I had the second site set up and working correctly on the second ip address, but didn’t consider that I was only testing inside the firewall and never tested from the outside. It’s working fine now - thanks for pointing me in the right direction.