CERTSAGE Fails with Error

I just don't get the change in behavior for the cpanel subdomain. A recent "upgrade" of cPanel perhaps?

I'll try switching back to the Basic Nameservers. It will take a while

Please keep us posted. You've got me very curious.

Will do. Where is certsage.com hosted?

GoDaddy registered and webhosted.

I'll let you know what happens.