You don't know what you don't know until someone tells you that you don't know!
I followed the instructions at this link to install the cPanel plugin:
This took only a couple of minutes including the WHM changes. The one step this instruction link is missing is the last one. After making the WHM changes, I had to log in to cPanel and click the "Run Auto SSL" button in the SSL section. (I am including this information for other newbies (like me) that may find this thread!)
Viola! Page works!
I spent DAYS trying to figure this out and the correct solution took minutes!! Thank you again!!!! I had no idea there was a cPanel plugin!